When no heads are better than one? OdessaDecember 11, 2016
“Two heads are better than one” is an old idiom which can occasionally be true.
“Great minds think alike” is another – although perhaps “great minds generally think alone” is more accurate.
How about “No heads are better than one”? It is an idiom that will probably prove to be true of the management of the Tuzly Lagoons National Park in Odessa.
A competition was recently held by the Regional State Administration Ecology Department to transparently select a head of the aforementioned national park, The incumbent for 30 years, Ivan Rusev decided not to take part in the competition for reasons of pride (it appears). To be fair Mr Rusev he can take pride in what he has achieved during his tenure and perhaps considers himself to know far more about the ecology of the national parks in Odessa than those that would scrutinise his necessarily submitted documents, or ask him questions.
How costly that pride will be for the ecology and management of the national parks in Odessa region remains to be seen.
For those entering he competition for the position, it was scored from a grand total of 135 points. The winner, Vitaly Chakir managed to score a miserable 42 points – or 31.1%
So either unprepared or simply clueless was Mr Chakir that he could not basic questions such as what an ecosystem is, or which fish, if any, live in the lagoons he will now apparently manage.
Indeed, even without such very basic knowledge and with his 31.1% score, Odessa Regional Authority Ecology Department has recommended he be appointed.
Lo, a reader is left to ponder just how abysmal a candidate must be before Odessa RSA will declare them to be so, or who is behind Mr Chakir and why? (Rumour would have it Batkivshchyna local MP Mogilnikov for access to resources in the park.)
It is perhaps only in politics where such a dismal result and complete lack of professional understanding can actually mean victory – yet this is not a political position but one of civil service.
However because it is not a political position does not mean it is not a political decision within the RSA Ecology Department that Mr Chakir would emerge the winner – and that may explain why he simply could not even be bothered to attempt to do even the most basic of preparation for examinations and interviews.
Unfortunately, when those interviews hit YouTube then questions will be rightly asked how the appointment of such a clearly sub-standard candidate can occur. Perhaps the Odessa RSA will now be shamed into reversing this decision and holding the competition again. Perhaps the environmentalists of Odessa will create sufficient unfavourable noise that the Ministry in Kyiv will take note – particularly when the 15th December sees the closing date for candidates to replace Mr Saakashvili as Governor and eyes will inevitably turn to Odessa once again.
(Thus far there are 3 candidates for Governor – Alexandr Ostapenko, Garik Korogodski and Vasyly Horbal.)
However, for the professional and qualified staff that will now have to work under the guidance of Mr Chakir, clearly “no heads are better than one”.