NATO statement – Ukraine “Unprecedented”?

May 27, 2010

NATO is calling Ukrainian interaction with it “unprecidented”……

Interfax-Ukraine NATO has said there is no precedent to the behavior of Ukraine, which has been working with the Alliance in the frame of the Annual National Program, and yet at the same time announced that it has no plans to join the alliance.

“It is an unprecedented experience for a country, which has been working in the frames of the Annual National Program, not to want to become NATO member,” NATO Assistant Secretary General for Defense Policy and Planning Jiri Sedivy said at a meeting with Ukrainian reporters.

At the same time, the NATO representative has said that this issue is not a matter of discussion within the alliance. NATO respects Ukraine’s decisions, Sedivy said.

How are you supposed to read that statement? 

Ukraine is doing everything that NATO could possibly hope for……but why doesn’t it want to join us?

Well, apart from it being unconstitutional to put a new foreign base or troops on Ukrainian soil, (although there is a clause for extending existing leases as employed to allow the RBSF to stay longer), the vast majority of the Ukrainian public are still anti NATO.

Firstly, Ukraine cannot afford to upgrade its military to meet NATO standards and there are numerous NATO members who seem to be in a much worse economic situation than Ukraine and therefore cannot afford to assist in this upgrade.

Secondly, as I have already said, the Ukrainian Constitution specifically forbids new foreign bases or troops on Ukrainian soil.

Thirdly, the current government is seeking non-aliegned status and even possibly internationally recognised neutral status and plays similar war games with the CIS members as well.

Lastly it would be a diplomatic and political nightmare for Ukraine to enter NATO and be the immediate border with Russia who still view NATO with some suspicion……and not just a nightmare for Ukraine but NATO itself in the current climate.

Why is it unprecidented for a neighbour to want to engage in mutually beneficial enterprises but not want to join the club? 

Why is it so hard to believe Ukraine does not want to join NATO……..or any other military block?

When NATO had the chance to allow Ukraine in the club in GW Bush’s swan song era, France, Germany, Italy and Spain were all against it with a pro NATO President sat in power in Ukraine.  Now there is a president who is not interested in joining, NATO wants to know why when cooperation is still high?

Why do such organsiations see everything as “all or nothing”?

My personal view, as well documented here historically, is that Ukraine should seek internationally recognised neutrality eventually and in the mean time, I would be pleased to see a continued path of non-aliegnment militarily…….and keeping good relations and bilateral interests served with both NATO and the CIS nations.

Be happy in NATO, you are getting cooperation without the financial or geopolitical fallout!

One comment

  1. […] NATO statement – Ukraine “Unprecedented”? « Odessablog’s Blog […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: